Wednesday, May 29, 2013

Tôi thích uống cà phê sữa đặc. Tôi cũng đặt câu hỏi về tình yêu của họ.

As I was finishing the book A Farewell to Arms a theme that could not be avoided was the lack of religion and love, throughout the entire novel. Although it may not have been as prominent in book two, it is revisited in the last chapters of the book. their entire relationship seems far too rushed and unrealistic.  Earlier they both blatantly state that they do not love each other, but at the end they have the gall to think that they are in love. Although it may sound odd, the child of Henry and Catherine symbolizes their relationship: it was never alive to begin with. Their child is the proof of their love for each other, but there was no love. When his very own son was born he “felt no feeling of fatherhood” (325).  Moreover he doesn’t act shocked at all, instead he seems more disappointed than sad, “poor little kid” (326). Not to mention when Catherine is on her death bed she says many contradicting things (not uncommon for her).  First she states that she doesn’t want Henry to touch her, but then follows up with  “you can touch me all you want”, further showing her contradicting personality. I theorize that her first response is her true feelings, but corrects herself for Henry’s sake with her second statement; showing the absence of true love, since she is not being honest with herself, she cannot be honest with Henry. .  Earlier in the novel Catherine describes how Henry is her religion and “all that I’ve got” since “I [Catherine] haven’t any religion” (116).  This is further implied when Henry desperately prays to God, or his old faith which he abandoned. As I said in an earlier post  religion acts as a safety net, and these two consider each other their “religion”; a net to catch them when things become grim or hopeless. When Catherine dies, Henry loses this net and has nothing left to hold onto, explaining the abrupt ending to the book. In his mind his life is over and as narrator that also includes his story.

                I’ve noticed that in today’s culture many people consider themselves in madly love. Personally, I scorn people who think like this. To be truly in love, there must be equal ground and time invested. No one wants to be the person walking down the aisle with doubts in their mind. Though there is “faith” in today’s world, I do not agree with all of the “faiths” in modern day society. We have grown to be superficial and material based society, praising luxury goods and how they represent our status. Instead of traditional values of family, honor and integrity.

1 comment:

  1. I totally agree with you when you describe Henry and Catherine’s love for each other as rushed. I even feel as if their love was fake, since their communication towards one another lacked an emotional connection. Also, the way Henry and Catherine spoke to each other, felt as if the words didn’t have any true meaning or significance behind them. For example, the fact that they never said, “I love you” to each other is a true testament of their love. Their relationship had no life to it and the baby’s death was a significant parallel to their unrealistic and rushed “love”.

    ReplyDelete